Census place · GEOID 3666828 · Suffolk County
Shelter Island, NY ZIP codes
2 ZIP/ZCTAs intersecting this Census place (CDP) in Suffolk County.
U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 2019–2023 5-year (vintage 2023). Geography: Census place Shelter Island (GEOID 3666828). Methodology
Combined population of ZIP/ZCTAs intersecting this place: 3,279 (2 ZIPs).
Combined population of ZIP/ZCTAs intersecting this place. Each intersecting ZIP contributes its full ZCTA population; overlap percents are descriptive only. This is not the Census place ACS headline above. Methodology
Map of Shelter Island, NY

ZIP/ZCTA overlap with Shelter Island
Population overlap
Share of each ZIP/ZCTA’s population located within Shelter Island, based on ZIP Code Database place-overlap data. This is a population measure, not land-area overlap or the Census-place population.
ZIP Code Database place-overlap table, field percent_of_zip_population_in_place, keyed by place_geoid. Not ACS 2019–2023. Overlap vintage is the shipped overlap table and is separate from ACS. Methodology
ZIP codes intersecting Shelter Island
| ZIP | City | County | Population | Income |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 11964 | Shelter Island | Suffolk County | 2,858 | $129,826 |
| 11965 | Shelter Island Heights | Suffolk County | 421 | — |